Skip to main content

Contesting the Probate Process: What You Need to Know

Contesting the probate process can be a challenging task. You’ll need to understand probate laws, identify valid reasons for contesting a will, and be prepared for any legal consequences.

Disputes could arise from unfair asset distribution, invalid wills, or undue influence. To challenge a will, you’ll need to confirm its validity, identify executor misconduct, or file a caveat with the probate court.

Contesting can lead to significant inheritance delays, high litigation costs, and familial stress. Stick with us, and we’ll provide the all-important insights into this complex process.

Understanding the Probate Process

To navigate probate, you first need to understand what it entails and how it works. It’s a legal process that involves estate administration after someone’s death. The probate court’s role is pivotal, ensuring the deceased’s debts are paid and remaining assets are distributed according to their will, if one exists.

Understanding probate timelines is important. They can vary but generally, you’re looking at a period of six months to a year, sometimes longer. Be prepared for potential delays due to the court’s workload or disputes among beneficiaries.

Reasons for Contesting Probate

While you’re getting a grip on the basics of probate, it’s equally important to understand why you might have a valid reason to contest it. This often stems from inheritance disputes – you might feel that the proposed distribution of assets is unfair or that someone is unjustly left out. Disputes can also arise over the interpretation of the will’s language.

Invalid wills are another common reason for contesting probate. If the will wasn’t properly executed or doesn’t comply with legal requirements, it’s deemed invalid. This can occur if the will lacks a witness, an important aspect of a valid will.

Undue influence is also a significant issue that can lead to probate being contested. If you suspect that the decedent was coerced or manipulated into writing their will a certain way, this constitutes undue influence.

Steps to Challenge a Will

If you’re considering challenging a will, you’ll need to carefully navigate a set of legal steps to make sure your case is heard.

Typically you would begin by scrutinizing the will validity. Confirm it was signed in the presence of two witnesses and that the will was signed with Mental Capacity, meaning, they were of sound mind when making the will. If you suspect the will was made under Undue Influence, pressure or manipulation, you can contest it.

Now consider whether there’s been executor misconduct. If the person responsible for executing the will has been dishonest or negligent, this could form the basis of your challenge.

To proceed, you’ll need to file with the probate court to prevent the will from being executed until your claim is resolved. You also must be an ‘interested party’ – typically a beneficiary or someone who’d have inheritance rights if the will was deemed invalid.

It’s also equally important to comprehend the legal consequences that could arise from contesting a will. Potential repercussions can be severe and far-reaching, impacting not just your financial situation but also your relationships with other family members.

If you’re unsuccessful in your challenge, you may be left footing the bill for both your legal fees and those of the opposing party. This financial burden can be substantial, particularly if the dispute drags on for a long period. The probate process can also be prolonged significantly when a will is contested, meaning you could be waiting for years to receive any inheritance.

Familial strain is another heavy burden that often arises from contesting a will and can result in emotional stress and strained relationships among family members. This is often the case when siblings or close relatives are pitted against each other in court.

Lastly, legal penalties may also be imposed if the court finds that your contest was frivolous or without merit. This could range from fines to sanctions, adding to your overall costs. So make sure to consider the potential upsides and downsides before you move in the direction of contesting a will to avoid any potentially avoidable negative consequence.

If you need help with your probate process in Virginia please reach out to Asurest for help!

Disclaimer: This material is intended for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.  Responses to inquiries, whether by email, telephone, or other means, do not constitute legal advice, nor do they create or imply the existence of an attorney-client relationship.

Written By
Matthew Reinaker
April 15, 2024
Table of Contents